A Letter of Advice by Sir Robert Gordon, 1620.

Wade Cormack is the post-holder for the Royal Dornoch PhD Studentship at the Centre for History, University fo the Highlands and Islands. His research explores early-modern sport and cultural history of the Moray Firth.

While children should always listen to their elders, whether they do or not is totally up to them! The year was 1620 and eleven-year old John, the 13th Earl of Sutherland, received a letter of advice from his uncle and tutor, Sir Robert Gordon. Sir Robert wanted John to become a successful leader, a calculated but kind master, a learned man, and someone respected throughout the land. His advice covered disparate topics, from the vices of man, how to select a proper wife and how to administer his estate effectively. He also instructed him on the themes of sport, education and ‘civility’.

Robert Gordon was born at Dunrobin Castle in 1580 and was the fourth son of the 11th Earl of Sutherland. Initially he was educated in Dornoch before leaving for St Andrews, Edinburgh, then continuing his education on the Continent at Saumur, Poitier, Bourges, finishing with six months in Paris. Along the way he became a student of Neo-Stoicism. In 1606 he was at the court of King James VI and I where he was subsequently admitted as a Gentleman to the Bedchamber and was knighted. These influential positions gave him direct access to King James and he began his long political career.

After the death of the 12th Earl of Sutherland in 1615, Sir Robert became the tutor to his six-year old nephew. He set John’s affairs in order and sent him to school in Dornoch. During these schooldays we find the first references known to date of golf being played in town. The Earl’s expenses show that ‘Item ten poundis guven this yeir for bowes, arroes, golff clubbes, and balls, with other necessars for his L[ordship’s] exercise’. Sir Robert was an accomplished archer himself, winning the silver arrow in Edinburgh during the King’s visit in 1617. He was a proponent of sport and believed it was a crucial part of education. Sir Robert solidified Dornoch’s reputation for sport in 1630 with his A Genealogical History of the Earldom of Sutherland. He famously stated ‘About this toun… ther are the fairest and largest linkes…of any pairt of Scotland, fitt for archery, goffing, ryding, and all otherexercise; they doe surpasse the feilds of Montrose or St Andrews.’

As the Genealogical History existed only in manuscript copies for nearly 200 years, the promotion of Dornoch’s links was for the eyes of the Earls of Sutherland. However, Sir Robert’s Letter of Advice shows broad participation in sport. He urged John to ‘Cherishe your countreymen and train them vp in all kynd of honest exercise, such as hunting, ryding, archerie, shooting with the gun, gofing, jumping, running, swimming and such lyk’. Golf in this region was not just an elite preserve then, but was for all of the Earl’s countrymen. Although the direct references to golf in Dornoch fade from then until the nineteenth century, this evidence suggests it was widely played.

Young men were prepared for manhood and leadership through martial activities and a good education. Although ‘gofing’ had been previously restricted by the Scottish kings because it was of no military benefit, Sir Robert felt it was acceptable. Football, however, another sport restricted on the same grounds, was not recommended to John: ‘footeball [w]as a dangerous and vnprofitable exercise’. Sir Robert’s reasoning for this was probably because in many cases football became a riotous event, considered to cause great disruption and damage to people and communities. The disruptions caused by golf, by comparison, were limited.

ImageThe Royal Dornoch Links 1900 (Image Courtesy of HistoryLinks Image Library)

Sir Robert was also keen to ‘improve’ the Sutherland lands, especially Dornoch. In 1609 the Statutes of Iona promoted the assimilation of the western Highlands and Islands into a Lowland culture. As an influential man at the court of King James, Sir Robert would have been involved in discussions on how to accomplish this. Sir Robert’s ideas on the importance of English language education and literacy; on ideas of civility; on sport; and on how to bring up young men, noble and commoner, for the good and cohesion of the realm, were influential at the highest level. Sir Robert believed the best way to transform the people of Sutherland was to: ‘plant schooles in ewerie corner in the countrey to instruct the youth to speak Inglishe. Let your cheif scooles for learning be at Dornoche, and perswade the gentlemen of your countrey to bestowe lairglie vpon ther children to make them schollers, for so shall they be fittest for your serwice. Preasse to ciwilize your countrey and the inhabitants therof, not onlie in this poynt, but lykwyse in all other things which yow shall obserwe abrod in your trawells among other nations.’ Sir Robert then advised John to ‘erect a biblio-theck in Dornoch and fill it with sufficient store of books, boith for your credit and the weell of this countrey, to amend ther ignorance which increases through laik of books’.

From a child’s perspective, Sir Robert’s Letter of Advice was rather daunting. Judging by his later character, John internalised much of his uncle’s advice though. Moreover, he continued to support sport, education and ‘civility’, and passed these lessons to his sons, who continued the tradition of Sutherland men playing golf, being well-read and educated. Nearly 400 years later, the connection between golf and education continues in Dornoch, thanks to the collaboration of the University of the Highlands and Islands and the Royal Dornoch Golf Club to support and investigate that passion of Sir Robert’s: the place of sport in society.

National Library of Scotland, The Sutherland Papers, Dep. 313/1597.
Allan, David. Philosophy and Politics in Late Stuart Scotland. (East Lothian: 2000).
Fraser, William ed. The Sutherland Book. 3 Vols., (Edinburgh: 1892).
Gordon, Robert A Genealogical History of the Earldom of Sutherland from its Origin to the Year 1630: with a Continuation to the Year 1651. (Edinburgh: 1813).

Dornoch Diversions

This week’s post is written by Dr David Worthington, Head of the Centre for History at the University of the Highlands and Islands.

Golf clubs, golf balls, bows and arrows, saddles, books, paper, ink, and ‘other school necessaries’. Robert Gordon (1580-1656) bought all of these items during the 1610s while he was tutor to his nephew, a future earl of Sutherland. They suggest to me golf’s long association with Dornoch’s social, cultural and educational fortunes. It’s really exciting to consider that a much deeper exploration of this theme, and of the first 200 years of the sport’s association with the town, will be one of the major aspects of research to be conducted soon here at the UHI Centre for History, by means of the Royal Dornoch PhD Studentship. It’s a venture that’s been made possible by the generosity of the Royal Dornoch Golf Club and the UHI Development Office. It seems that from 1642 – when Gordon left east Sutherland for a new life in Moray – down to the mid-nineteenth century, golf slid into relative obscurity in the town. However, we are sure there are more documents to uncover not only regarding the history of golf in Dornoch, but also to indicate how local people have amused themselves more widely over the centuries.

In 1604, Patrick Stewart, ‘Black Patie’, second earl of Orkney (c.1566/7–1615), ‘passed his tyme a whyle at Dornogh, honorablie interteyned with comedies, and all other sports and recreations that Earl John [John Gordon, thirteenth earl of Sutherland] culd mak him’. What were these ‘sports and recreations’? In 1715, the town’s presbytery was exercised by the ‘gross and abominable practises in some places of the Country by Musick, playing and dancing at Lykwakes, and by promiscuous dancing at that and other occasions’. Later that century, the Reverend Mr John Bethune suggested the townspeople’s ability to occasionally let their hair down: ‘if they relax of their usual parsimony at fairs and other occasional meetings, they know how to make amends by habitual economy and absteniousness’.

Sport and games were certainly part of this recreation then. Football was well-known from the late sixteenth century. Donald Sage remembered a variety of shinty – perhaps akin to the ‘knotty’ that could have been found in Caithness – which was flourishing on holy days in Dornoch at the start of the nineteenth century. Sage also tells us about the annual cockfights. As early as 1856, the Inverness Advertiser mentioned a cricket ‘Match between Tain & Golspie at the links of Dornoch’. By the early twentieth century one of the town’s winter institutions was ‘bools’ which was played ‘between the east and west sides of the burn, and next day between married and single. The losers had to pay for a quarter of meal for the poor.’ By 1913 this old form of bowling seems to have been replaced as local residents were campaigning for the formation of a Tennis and Bowling Club. Shortly after, Dornoch Bowling Club was founded. We can also read, through the online HistoryLinks Image Library, of a ‘Sutherland Bonspiel Feb 1st 1912 Won by R. R. Johnstone’. By the time of the Third Statistical Account (1986), Dornoch residents were enjoying tennis, badminton, basketball and squash in addition to these earlier sports. The town could also boast of its own annual festival and sports week, Highland Games and school playing fields. The development of sport and cultural life in Dornoch had moved beyond the first ‘outward-nine’.

Hector M. Mackay, Old Dornoch: Its Traditions and Legends (Dingwall, 1920)

Reverend Charles D. Bentinck, Dornoch: cathedral and parish (Inverness, 1926).

Michael Hook, A History of the Royal Burgh of Dornoch (Dornoch, 2005).


Black and white photo of Dornoch footballers, early 1900s. Back l to r: Angie Munro (gardener), Sutherlands (Gruids), Jim Leslie (Embo St), R Grant (Captain). Middle l to r: Jim Mackay (Tornaver), WH Innes (painter), Bob Murray (chemist). Front l to r: J Macintosh (Embo Farm), A Gillespie (paper shop), Walty Matheson (golfer, killed in France).

Image courtesy of Historylinks Image Library